Abandon
By Meg Cabot
Pierce Olivera is a sixteen year old who died last year. This year, however, she is trying to start anew… though she lacks any motivation to do so since the incident…. Of course, going to the Underworld would certainly leave a mark on anyone who visited. Although… typically no one actually leaves the Underworld.
When I stumbled upon this book I had never read anything by Meg Cabot before. While her name sounded familiar I had to do a little research to remind myself why I knew it. This wasn’t her first rodeo, anyone else remember growing up watching the Princess Diaries movies? Perhaps you even read some of those books. Well, that’s Meg Cabot’s work.
The thing is I wouldn’t have pegged this as something an experienced writer would have published. As another reviewer put it, reading this without any prior knowledge one would assume it was someone’s first novel. Had it been a first novel I would probably give the author a break and say something about how they had a lot of promise and, with a little elbow grease, could certainly polish up their skills to be a great writer.
Abandon is a story about a girl who, as I mentioned, died and came back to life. Sort of. While dead, however, she meets a guy named John. Someone she has met before… which the author tells us about through various flashbacks that utterly shatter your immersion. When reading a novel you expect to be enveloped into a world. Your mind absorbed by the written word. For some reason the first, I’d say about half, of this book is extremely stilted. It is choppy and breaks your train of thought time and again. And. It’s. Annoying.
At first I thought she just had a very unique writing style, except that it doesn’t continue throughout the entire book. After about midway the story smooths out and is fairly easy to follow. So much so that you get wrapped up in it and have a hard time returning to normal life stuffs later.
Now as far as character development goes….. *sigh*…. I mean… I guess it’s there… kind of? Pierce has sort of a history. She has seen people go through some real challenges and, despite her apathy with life itself, she struggles with trying to help people for various reasons. But you are basically told most of this, you don’t really see her grow. The main guy likes her because she’s…..pretty. That more or less sums it up. And aside from a short couple of interactions between our MC and John (where there isn’t much exchange), there’s little available to hang a “relationship” on.
We come to a point about two thirds through the story and find out about John from an acquaintance. This guy essentially spoon-feeds her (and you as the reader) whatever is needed to bring this story to an end. Pierce doesn’t do the hard work. She doesn’t go investigating, there’s literally no motivation for her to do anything. She’s just like ‘I died, met this guy, he wants me to be with him forever because I’m pretty, and I’m not sure I want that’. That’s it.
There’s just a lot here to be desired. There’s a lot of loose ends, which I get because it is a series, but there are some bare bones that need some meat. It just feels like it’s lacking. There are relationships that should be fleshed out more, personal growth from various characters, people that just kind of dropped off…
Some people compared this to Twilight, and I guess the weird controlling kind of thing could come off as similar… but I would say Twilight gives reasons why Edward is controlling – Bella is basically a walking disaster. John is just bossy.
Okay… enough with the bad….
I really enjoyed this story once the flashbacks and such died off. I felt like I could vividly picture where Pierce was and her peers were at least interesting. There’s a disconnect with Pierce that’s pretty relatable even if it’s not for the same reasons. I do plan to finish this series because it was, oddly enough, hard for me to put down. There comes a time where you begin to kind of gloss over the shallowness of some of the writing and just enjoy the story for what it is.
There is a hint of greek mythology with this story, but as someone who greatly enjoys that subject I can’t say that it really plays a major role in the overall work. It has its place but doesn’t stand alone.
As I said, I do plan on reading the rest of the series. It has enough to go on that I want to know how things turn out. I liked Abandon. I just wish there was more to this portion of the story.
You must be logged in to post a comment.